A Vegetable Garden without Soil

An isometric illustration of a hydroponic greenhouse.
Science and technology don’t stand in place: scientists around the world work to ensure that the production of fresh and healthy foods is simple, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly. So, in place of classic garden beds and greenhouses comes hydroponics: growing plants in nutrient solutions without soil.

Topic Last Updated on 02-07-2024

The History of Hydroponics

The idea of growing plants without soil is not new. Back in 1699, the English naturalist John Woodward described his experiments growing peppermint in a soilless environment. The plant died in desalinated, distilled water, but it continued to grow in untreated water. Probably, Woodward reasoned, the mint extracts something from the water that is necessary for growth.

Now we know that the plant needs many mineral substances for normal growth and development, including calcium (Ca), iron (Fe), potassium (K), magnesium (Mg), phosphorus (P), and sulfur (S). Plants take them from the soil (some predators, like Venus flytraps, get them from the bodies of their victims), but for this, there must be water in the soil to dissolve the mineral substances, making them accessible to the roots. Plants without soil, they just require mineral substances from it. Woodward’s experiments gave rise to much reflection, but, until the beginning of the 20th century, the cultivation of plants without soil remained an area of exclusively scientific interest.

Garden without soil
The idea of hydroponics is that soil is not an obligatory companion of plants, but is rather just support for it. Therefore, the substrate can have many different compositions — coconut fiber, sawdust, mineral wool, crushed stone, expanded clay, etc. It is only important that it conducts moisture well, allows air to circulate, and does not chemically react with the nutrient solution. By the way, moist air can also serve as a substrate (this is called aeroponics)

Plants without soil | The Evolution of Hydroponics

In the 1930s, American biologist William F. Gericke brought hydroponics out of the laboratory and into the light. He insisted that growing plants on a large scale without soil, but instead on nutrient solutions, is not only possible but also makes a lot of sense. His colleagues were skeptical about this idea at first, but when Gericke showed them tomato shrubs a few yards tall that were grown with an aqueous solution of mineral substances, they changed their mind.

The University of California, where Gericke worked, even allocated huge areas for such experimental greenhouses. He called his revolutionary method “aquaculture,” but there was some confusion: the word was already in use for the breeding of aquatic organisms (fish, algae, mollusks). It was then that he introduced a new term— hydroponics— which we still use to this day, as it carries the understanding that this is the cultivation of plants using nutrient solutions and without soil.

The first mention of the commercial use of hydroponics was in 1938 when Time magazine published an article about tiny Wake Island in the Pacific Ocean, where Pan American Airways planes landed for refueling. Among other things, the article said that barrels with mineralized water, in which beans, tomatoes, and other vegetables were grown, were installed on the island. This food was intended for the aircraft crew. During World War II, there were more of these kinds of farms: the military needed fresh vegetables, and it was difficult to deliver them. Today, hydroponics is widely used all over the world. For example, NASA is studying the possibility of growing vegetables on a spaceship in a closed ecological life-support system. The success of such an experiment will lead to new prospects for space travel.

NASA is studying the prospects of growing vegetables in space
NASA is studying the prospects of growing vegetables in space

Plants without soil | Why hydroponics?

Does not require soil
Does Not Require Soil​
A reusable substrate is used
Simple technology
Simple Technology​
Does not require special skills or knowledge
Year-Round Harvests
Year-Round Harvests​
Fast growth in any season
Control
Control
The composition of the nutrient solution can be changed
Eco-friendly
Eco-Friendly​
Small quantity of fertilizers and pesticides
Water-efficient
Water-Efficient​
Through water reuse

Why Water is Better than Soil

 Humankind has been growing fruit and vegetables for thousands of years. Why spend money on technological development when you can just stick a plant in the ground? Because hydroponics has a lot of advantages. It gives us the opportunity to grow food in places where traditional agriculture is impossible. In arid climates, like Israel and Egypt, hydroponics has been used for several decades.

Thanks to this method, it became possible to purchase locally-produced food on the market, rather than importing these products from other countries at a high cost. Similarly, hydroponics are needed where space is limited, even for humans. For example, in Bermuda, these systems occupy only 20 % of the amount of land that would be required for crops. In regions that are cold and have few sunny days, hydroponics allows you to harvest a high yield of local vegetables and fruits. In cities with poor ecology, the cultivation of plants without soil solves several problems at once: greenery appears, which is typically rare in densely built-up areas, and along with it, food products start to grow in homes and offices, which leads to almost unlimited access to fresh, healthy food. 

Hydroponic garden
Hydroponic garden

The Environmental Benefits of Hydroponics

The deciding argument in favor of hydroponics is the high environmental friendliness of this type of agriculture. The water circulates in a closed system: it passes through purification systems, is enriched with nutrients, and again flows to the plants. This is extremely important for areas where there is little water, such as in the Middle East and parts of Africa. Besides, almost no pesticides are required: the conditions on farms are practically sterile, and hydroponics require only about 25 % of the amount of fertilizer necessary for growing plants in soil. This approach saves money and contributes to the preservation of the environment. Finally, since the food is grown on-site, there is no need for it to be transported — again, both the producer and nature benefit.

Vertical farms

Vertical farms

In the near future, the growth of the world’s population will lead to a shortage of arable land. Vertical farms allow us not only to abandon soil but also to use space economically, placing hydroponic installations in several tiers.

Subscribe to read in full

Get Unlimited Digital Access for all issues

The subscription renews automatically. You can unsubscribe at any time

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related Articles

An astronaut floating in space above the earth, surrounded by particles and positrons.

Subscribe to continue reading

Get 20% off your first order!